| Controls selected by risk ISO/IEC 27001 6.1.2 and 6.1.3 | yesthe Statement of Applicability is computed; 2.0.0 candidate | noa risk exists only after assessment | partialjoined only through threats | no | tool onlynot in the exchange format | no |
| Risk acceptance on record | yesapprover, date, rationale; 2.0.0 candidate | partialno field for approver or date | partialno approver, no date | no | tool onlyapprover, date, expiry | yesfor check results: authority, time, reason |
| Every decision traceable | partialweakening needs an approved exception; an author per change is optional and reported | partialwho and when per document only | partiala rationale, no author | no | partialan audit log; no reason enforced | partialan optional remark per change |
| Vendor recommendations kept apart from the controls | yesenforced on import; 2.0.0 candidate | yescomponent definitions; adoption is a copy | partialseparate files, no authority boundary | partialone file may also define the standard | partiala library update can rewrite assessments | partialthe vendor's checks still decide |
| Exceptions and findings with deadlines | yestyped due dates; a review date on exceptions, reported once passed | yesrisk deadlines, milestones | no | partialevidence expiry only | tool onlyexception expiry, due dates | no |
| Automated checks as code, in any language | yesverdict recomputed from the observation; no runner; 2.0.0 candidate | partialruns recorded, no check logic | partialruns recorded, logic outside the format | partiala command line as text | partialimports other tools' results | partialany language only outside SCAP conformance |
| One chain from clause to implementation, check run and evidence file | yescheck runs: 2.0.0 candidate | yeswith a hash on the evidence | partialno implementation record | partialattachments carry no hash | partialtool results not linked to controls | partialtext references, no hashes |
| Several languages in one object | yesa language map | no | no | no | yesa translations map | yesxml:lang |
| A signature that survives repackaging | yesalso after a round trip through OSCAL | nobyte hashes only | nobundle bytes, signed by tooling | partiallost in the XML and protobuf forms | no | partialre-indenting breaks it |
| Extensible by facets a contract that is enforced, pinned, and stops a tool that does not understand it | yesschema pinned by digest; unknown semantics stop the tool | partialnamespaced props, no schema behind them | partialclosed schemas; a profile can narrow, not add | partialstring properties, optional registry | tool onlythe format ignores unknown keys | partialforeign elements checked laxly |